In a recent overhaul of its approach to platform safety, Twitch, the popular live-streaming service owned by Amazon, has announced the disbandment of its existing Safety Advisory Council. Instead, the platform will integrate known and trusted figures within its community, referred to as Twitch Ambassadors, to form a revamped council. This seems to be an attempt to inject fresh perspectives and enhance the effectiveness of addressing safety on the ever-evolving platform. These shifts come amidst other tech industry trends where companies are streamlining operations and often revisiting the structures in place for community safety and moderation.
Disbandment of the Original Twitch Safety Advisory Council
"Giant Twitch Logo LEGO Build Time-lapse" by BrickinNick is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0.
Composition and Role of the Initial Council
The original Twitch Safety Advisory Council, established by Twitch in May 2020, was composed of a diverse group of nine members, including Twitch streamers, professional moderators, and outside experts with experience in online harassment and safety issues. This council was designed to bolster Twitch’s efforts in tackling trust and safety concerns by consulting on drafting new policies, updating existing ones, and developing features aimed at improving moderation and user protection. Their advisory role also covered issues ranging from hate raids targeting marginalized groups to nudity and the behavior of banned users, largely influencing Twitch's strategic decisions on these fronts.
Reasons for Terminating Contracts
The decision to disband the original council came abruptly as Twitch announced it would not renew the existing contracts, which were scheduled to conclude on May 31, 2024. This step was communicated during a meeting on May 6, where council members were informed via email about the cessation of their roles and the non-issuance of their anticipated second-half payments for the year. The termination follows industry trends where companies, particularly in the tech sector, have scaled back on investments in ethics and safety teams to cut costs amidst economic pressures. This shift is in spite of growing concerns over cyberbullying and the spread of misinformation online - a notable reevaluation of resource allocation within the company.
Introduction of Twitch Ambassadors as New Council Members
Image by Kyra Starr from Pixabay
Profile of Twitch Ambassadors
The new members of the revamped Safety Advisory Council are selected from the Twitch Ambassadors program, which includes over 180 streamers recognized for their positive contributions to the community. These ambassadors are not just popular figures on the platform but are also esteemed for their active engagement and leadership within the Twitch user base. Their roles have allowed them to gain firsthand experience in the platform's safety initiatives, making them well-prepared to offer fresh and diverse perspectives on the advisory council.
Expected Roles and Responsibilities in the New Framework
With the transition to using Twitch Ambassadors as council members, the expectation is that these individuals will bring their in-depth understanding of the community dynamics to guide Twitch's safety policies and community interactions effectively. Their responsibilities will encompass a broad spectrum of safety-related issues such as enhancing user protection against abuse, advising on content moderation practices, and ensuring the platform remains inclusive and safe for all users. By leveraging their experiences, Twitch aims to maintain an adaptive and responsive approach to user safety, reflective of the community's evolving needs.
Controversy Over Compensation
One of the controversies emerging from this transition relates to the compensation of the new council members. In the previous setup, council members were compensated between $10,000 and $20,000 per year, depending on contract lengths. However, with the shift to the ambassador-based council, Twitch has not confirmed whether these new members will receive similar remuneration. This lack of clarity around compensation has sparked discussions within the community, as it touches on the value and recognition of the important work these advisors are expected to contribute to the platform’s safety landscape.
Implications of the Revamp on Twitch's Safety Policies
Photo by Caspar Camille Rubin on Unsplash
Potential Impact on Moderation and User Safety
The restructuring of Twitch’s Safety Advisory Council involves replacing the initial group of online safety experts and moderated streamers with Twitch Ambassadors. This is a crucial change in the oversight of user safety and content moderation, previously guided by a mix of industry experts and seasoned streamers. The Ambassadors, known for their positive influence within the community, are expected to bring firsthand experiences that might lead to more targeted and community-focused safety measures.
However, transitioning from a professional advisory board to a more peer-led committee raises questions about consistency and the depth of expertise in handling complex safety challenges, such as cyberbullying and the spread of misinformation. Given the previous advisory's role in developing features to improve moderation and enhance protection for marginalized groups, it is crucial that the new council continues to prioritize these initiatives with equal or enhanced energy.
Reaction from the Twitch Community and Industry Observers
The response from the Twitch community and industry observers to the Safety Advisory Council's revamp has been mixed. While some community members are optimistic that the change might lend a fresher, more relatable face to safety governance, others are cautious about the practical implications of having ambassadors, who might lack the professional background in safety and moderation, in charge.
It's worth pointing that this move comes at a time when many tech companies are scaling back their ethics and safety operations to cut costs, potentially affecting the quality and effectiveness of governance. With initial council members being experts like Dr. Sameer Hinduja and Dr. T.L. Taylor, who brought specialized knowledge to the platform, their replacement with ambassadors might not fill the expertise gap that specialized safety issues demand.
Long-term Expectations from the Change
Looking forward, the Twitch community expects the revamped Safety Advisory Council to maintain, if not enhance, the platform's ability to address and manage safety concerns effectively. This includes the continuation of developing robust safety policies, especially concerning issues like hate raids and user protection policies. The integration of opinions from a diverse group of ambassadors could lead to innovative solutions that resonate more with the everyday user. Thus fostering an inclusive and respectful community environment.
However, it remains to be seen whether these ambassadors will have the adequate support and resources to influence meaningful change. Or if this revamp is merely a cost-cutting measure that could compromise the effectiveness of Twitch’s trust and safety protocols in the long run. The platform's ability to balance cost management with effective safety oversight will likely determine its success in maintaining a safe online environment for its users.
